Identical Particles

Preamble

All intrinsic properties of the particles are the same. I.e. mass, charge, spin. E.g. 2e-, 2p, 2n.

Non-identical particles (distinguishable). E.g. pe-, u-e-.

Example 1

Collide two particles, 1 and 2. If we have a detector D which detects the particles after the collision. Did it detect 1, 2, or both? Exchange-degeneracy.

Example 2

We have particle 1 at x=a and particle 2 at x=b. If they are distinguishable then exchanging them gives a different setup: |am1bm2|am2bm1. If they are indistinguishable then exchanging them gives the same setup: |am1bm2=|am2bm1.

Definition

The permutation operator P^ij is defined by P^ijΨ(r1,ε1;r2,ε2;;rj,εj;rj,εj;;rN,εN)=λΨ(r1,ε1;r2,ε2;;rj,εj;ri,εi;;rN,εN) with λ{1,1}. The λ can be found by applying the permutation operator twice.

For λ=1, we have symmetric wavefunctions, bosons, integer spin, e.g. H, D (Deuteron), γ,He,2p+2n. For λ=1, we have antisymmetric wavefunctions, fermions, half-integer spin, e.g. e,p,n,13C.

Can a fermion become a boson through an interaction, i.e. is there a V such that ΨS|V|ΨA0? If this was the case then applying the parity operator twice on either side, ΨS|P^VP^(|ΨA)=ΨS|V|ΨA. Thus, the matrix element must be zero.

Pauli Exclusion Principle

N-Particles

|ΨS=1N!(|Ψ1Ψ2ΨN+|Ψ2Ψ1ΨN++|Ψ1Ψ2ΨNΨN1+). The N! comes from the fact that there are N! factorial ways to permute.

|ΨA is given by Slater’s determinant. I.e. for the 3x3 case: 1N!|Ψ1(r1,ε1)Ψ2(r1,ε1)Ψ3(r1,ε1)Ψ1(r2,ε2)Ψ2(r2,ε2)Ψ3(r2,ε2)Ψ1(r3,ε3)Ψ2(r3,ε3)Ψ3(r3,ε3)|=1N![Ψ1(Ψ2Ψ3Ψ3Ψ2)Ψ2(Ψ1Ψ3Ψ3Ψ1)+Ψ3(Ψ1Ψ2Ψ2Ψ1)].

Distinguishable: |Ψ=nN|Ψn.

Permutations

Given N particles and N boxes then we have N! possible combinations to fill the boxes.

Given N particles and k boxes then we have N!(Nk)!=k!(Nk) possible permutations to fill the boxes.

How many $k-$combinations can we get? With combinations the boxes are unlabled hence ab and ba are the same. Then we have (Nk).

Note: (x+y)N=k=0N(Nk)xkyNk.

Two Particles in a Box

Etot=2π2mL2. For each particle, 2π22mL2(n12+n22). Then, we have |11 which is allowed for distinguishable and bosonic particles.

Etot=52π22mL2. For each particle, 2π22mL2(n12+n22). Then, we have |12,|21 which is allowed for distinguishable. Boson: 1/2(|12+|21). Fermion: 1/2(|12|21).

For more degrees of freedom, say spin, then a symmetric function would be both the coordinate and spin being symmetric or antisymmetric.

Z Electron Atom

We will not consider relativisitic corrections, and have spin-dependent terms and a stationary nucleus.

\(H = \sum_i^Z \frac{p_i^2}{2m} - \sum_i^Z \frac{Ze^2}{R_i} + \sum_{i

If we didn’t have the last term, H=iZHi. Hence, Ψ=Ψ1ΨZ.

How many terms does the last term have? Z(Z1)2=(Z2) terms.

The second term is roughly, Ze2RZ and the third is roughly e2RZ(Z1)2.

The second term is 4 times larger for helium, not a great perturbation. As we increase Z, we approach 2, which is definitely a great perturbation.

Central Field Approximation

H=iZ(pi22m+Vc(Ri))+V where \(V=-\sum_i^Z \frac{Ze^2}{R_i} + \sum_{i

So, if we can construct VC such that V is minimal, it becomes an excellent perturbation. Then, with the first term we have Ψ=Rn(r)Ym(Θ,ϕ).

Considering small Ri, the nuclear interaction potential should be just Ze2Ri. For large Ri, we have a nucleus of +Ze and the sea of electrons give a (Z1)e. Then we see a net interaction charge of e2Ri.

For hydrogenic atoms, E=iZEi with Ei=En. For non-hydrogenic atoms, Ei=En. The set of individual states with same En are called shells and occupied shells are electronic configuration. We have 2(2+1) degeneracy. Hence how many electrons can occupy each shell.

For $s$-electrons =0 hence we can only have 2 electrons. For $p$-electrons =1 hence we can only have 6 electrons. For $d$-electrons =2 hence we can only have 10 electrons.

Outer shell matters most for interactions.

The ground state of helium is 1s2: 2E1s the excited state is 1s12s1: E1s+E2s the second excited state is 1s12p1: E1s+E2p.

If n1n2 or 12 then we have 2(21+1)2(22+1)=4(21+1)(22+1) degeneracy. Then the degeneracy of 1s12s1 is 4(20+1)(20+1)=4.

If n1=n2 and 1=2 then we have (2(2+1)2)=(2+1)(4+1) total degeneracy.

The Helium Atom

H0Ψ=EΨ, H0=H1+H2, H=p122m+p222m+e2|R1R2|2e2R12e2R2=H0+Vp, E=E1n11+E2n22. Then, H0=p122m+p222m+Vc(R1)+Vc(R2).

Degeneracy:

  1. n1n212: 4(21+1)(22+1)
  2. n1=n21=2: (2+1)(4+1)

If we had a 1s2 state then we would have |Ψ=12Ψn11m1(|+|+)|100;100=Ψ1s(r1)Ψ1s(r2)12(|+|+). Spatial antisymmetric and spin symmetric OR Spatial symmetric and spin antisymmetric. The spin antisymmetric is only possible for the same spatial quantum numbers.

Vp=2e2R12e2R2+e2|R1R2|Vc(R1)Vc(R2).

Consider the 1s + 2s configuration. For our 4-fold degenerate space, we must find the 4 wavefunctions. |1S=|Ψspatial,S|Ψspin,A=ΨS|s=0,mS=0=ΨS|0,0=ΨS12(|+|+). |2S=|Ψspatial,A|Ψspin,S=12(|100;200|200;100){|10|11|11.

So, Ψ|V|Ψ=Ψspatial|V|Ψspatial. Note that the spin is unperturbed by our potential. From the spins, we see that our perturbation is already diagonal. I will call our two spatial wavefunctions by the spectroscopic notation. 1S|V|1S,3S|V|3S.

Then, V=12[d3r1d3r2|Ψ1s(r1)|2V|Ψ2s(r2)|2+d3r1d3r2|Ψ1s(r2)|2V|Ψ2s(r1)|2±d3r1d3r2Ψ1s(r1)Ψ2s(r2)VΨ1s(r2)Ψ2s(r1)±d3r1d3r2Ψ1s(r2)Ψ2s(r1)VΨ1s(r1)Ψ2s(r2)]=d3r1d3r2|Ψ1s(r1)|2V|Ψ2s(r2)|2±d3r1d3r2Ψ1s(r1)Ψ2s(r2)VΨ1s(r2)Ψ2s(r1). Note that V has five terms so we get a trivial 10 integrals to evaluate.

Consider the first integral.

d6r|Ψ1s(r1)|2V|Ψ2s(r2)|2=2e2(d3r1|Ψ1s(r1)|2r1+d3r2|Ψ1s(r2)|2r2)+e2d6r|Ψ1s(r1)|2|Ψ2s(r2)|2|r1r2|d3r1|Ψ1s(r1)|2Vc(r1)d3r2|Ψ2s(r2)|2Vc(r2)=2e2I+e2KI1I2=I+KI1I2.

The cross terms,

d3r1d3r2Ψ1s(r1)Ψ2s(r2)VΨ1s(r2)Ψ2s(r1)=2e2(d3r1Ψ1s(r1)Ψ2s(r1)r1d3r2Ψ2s(r2)Ψ1s(r2)+d3r2Ψ1s(r2)Ψ2s(r2)r2d3r1Ψ2s(r1)Ψ1s(r1))(=0)+e2d6rΨ1s(r1)Ψ2s(r2)Ψ1s(r2)Ψ2s(r1)|r1r2|d3r1Ψ1s(r1)Ψ2s(r1)Vc(r1)d3r2Ψ1s(r2)Ψ2s(r2)d3r1Ψ1s(r1)Ψ2s(r1)Vc(r1)d3r1Ψ1s(r1)Ψ2s(r1)=2e20+e2J00=J.

Note that I1,I2 are average energy for the central field for each electron. J is the exchange integral and is purely Quantum Mechanical.

Therefore, our full energies are E+=II1I2+K+J and E=II1I2+KJ. Thus, we get a 4-fold degeneracy split into 1-fold and 3-fold degeneracy split by the exchange interaction.

So, if Vc(ri)=2e2ri then V=e2|r1r2 and II1I2=0, Energies become K±J. But note that this only contributes to an energy shift, not the split.

The singlet state has the higher energy, E+ since it is the symmetric spin wavefunction. The triplet state has the higher energy, E since it is the antisymmetric spin wavefunction.

In the context of helium, the singlet state is called parahelium and the triplet is orthohelium.

Spectroscopic Notation

Recall: 2s+1L where s is total spin and L is total orbital. So, 1s2 gives 1S which as degeneracy (2L+1)(2s+1)=1.

Ansatz: 2p+2p1S,1D,3P3+3+9=15

For 1s+2s we have a non-degenerate 1S and 3-fold 3S.

1s21=0,2=0,s1=1/2L=0,S=01S.

2s+1LJ is also Spectroscopic, hence 1s21S0.

NOTE Full shells are non-degenerate since all possible states are already taken 1L. Also, note that holes = electrons. Hence 2p5=2p.

Hydrogen Molecule

Consider 2 hydrogen nuclei (a,b) with an electron each (1,2).

So, ra1 is the vector between nucleus a and electron 1. Our total set of vectors are: ra1,ra2,rab,rb1,rb2,r12.

The Hamiltonian is then, 22me(12+22)+e21r12e2(1ra1+1ra2+1rb1+1rb2) Let rab be a parameter of the system.

If rab then Ha1=22me12e2ra1,Hb2=22me22e2rb2. Thus, H0=Ha1+Hb2. The perturbation is then, V=e2r12e2(1ra2+1rb1).

So, H0Ψ1=E0Ψ1, Ψ1=Ψa(ra1)Ψb(rb2). Then, H0Ψ1=E0Ψ1=2EIΨ1.

The exchanged hamiltonian is then H0=Ha2+Hb1. Ha2=22m22e2ra2,Hb1=. Then, Ψ2=Ψa(ra2)Ψb(rb1) with the same energy, H0Ψ2=2EIΨ2.

Then the full Hamiltonian is H=H0+Va1,b2=H0+Va2,b1.

Our full wavefunction is then c1Ψ1+c2Ψ2+ϕ. Note that we will show |c2|=|c1|.

H1Ψ=EΨ=(2EI+ΔE)Ψ.

(1)c1HΨ1+C2HΨ2+Hϕ=(2E1+ΔE)(c1Ψ1+c2Ψ2+ϕ)c1Va1,b2Ψ1+c2Va2,b1Ψ2+Hϕ=2E1ϕ+(ΔE)(c1Ψ1+c2Ψ2+ϕ)(2)c1Va1,b2Ψ1=ΔEc1Ψ1(3)c2Va2,b1Ψ2=ΔEc2Ψ2(4)Hϕ=(2E1+ΔE)ϕ

Reducing by neglecting second-order perturbation,

(5)c1Va1,b2Ψ1=ΔEc1Ψ1(6)c2Va2,b1Ψ2=ΔEc2Ψ2(7)H0ϕ=H0ϕ=2E1ϕ

Then,

(8)(H02EI)ϕ=(ΔEVa1,b2)c1Ψ1+(ΔEVa2,b1)c2Ψ2.

Note the RHS is the inhomogeneity. If RHS is zero then, H0ϕ2E1ϕϕ=Ψ1 if H0 and ϕ=Ψ2 if H0.

For an inhomogenous equation, there is a solution only if the RHS is orthogonal to the solution of the homogenous equation. Then,

(9)[(ΔEVa1,b2)c1Ψ1+(ΔEVa2,b1)c2Ψ2]Ψ1d3r1d3r2=0(10)[(ΔEVa1,b2)c1Ψ1+(ΔEVa2,b1)c2Ψ2]Ψ2d3r1d3r2=0

Let,

(11)K=Va1,b2|Ψ1|2d3r1d3r2(12)K=Va2,b1|Ψ2|2d3r1d3r2(13)ΔE=ΔE|Ψ1,2|2d3r1d3r2(14)0>J=Va2,b1Ψ2Ψ1d3r1d3r2(15)0>J=Va1,b2Ψ1Ψ2d3r1d3r2

Gives us,

(16)ΔEc1c1K+ΔEc2Ψ2Ψ1d3r1d3r2c2J=0(17)ΔEc1c1K+ΔEc2|s|2c2J=0(18)ΔEc2c2K+ΔEc1Ψ1Ψ2d3r1d3r2c1J=0ΔEc2c2K+ΔEc1|s|2c1J=0

So,

(19)Ψ1Ψ2d3r1d3r2=Ψa(ra1)Ψb(rb1)d3r1Ψb(rb2)Ψa(ra2)d3r2(20)=SS(21)=|S|2.

Gives us,

(22)[ΔEK]c1+[ΔE|S|2J]c2=0(23)[ΔEK]c2+[ΔE|S|2J]c1=0.|ΔEKΔE|S|2JΔE|S|2JΔEK|=0(24)(ΔE)1=K+J1+|S|2(25)(ΔE)2=KJ1+|S|2.

The second is the symmetric solution c1=c2.

ΨS,Spatial=12(1+|S|2)(Ψ1+Ψ2). Then, ES=2E1+e2rab+KJ1+|S|2=2E1+e2rab+K+J|S|2K+J1+|S|2, which also includes the proton-proton energy. The second form is written so that you can treat the last term as a small correction.

ΨA,Spatial=12(1|S|2)(Ψ1Ψ2). EA=2E1+e2rab+K+J1+|S|2=2E1+e2rab+KJ|S|2KJ1|S|2. Thus, the exchange energy is the differentiating factor and since J<0 the antisymmetric wavefunction is higher energy.

20230428091950-identical_particles.org_20230512_094844.png

Bond length: rab,01.4a0, where the verticle reaches the x-axis. The bottom of the well is like a harmonic oscillator with ω02 given by the curvature of the bottom of the well: ω0=1md3ESdrab2. The height is the Diassociation energy D=4.38 eV.

  Theory Experiment
rab 0.735 A 0.753 A
ω0 4280 1/cm 4390 1/cm
D 4.37 eV 4.38 eV

Time Dependence

Consider, H1φa(r1)=Eaφa(r1) and H2φb(r2)=Ebφb(r2). (H1+H2+H12)Ψ=EΨ ΨA,S=12(φa(r1)φb(r2)φb(r1)φa(r2)). Then, EA,S=EA+EB+KJ. Consider, Ψ(0)=φa(r1)φb(r2)=12(ΨA(0)+ΨS(0)). At what time is the occupation reversed, Ψ(t)=φa(r2)φb(r1)?

From the superposition, we can time-evolve the state and find when the occupation is reversed,

Ψ(t)=12(ΨS(0)exp(iESt)+ΨA(0)exp(iEAt))=12(i(Ea+Eb+K)t)(ΨS(0)exp(iJt)+ΨA(0)exp(iJt))=12(i(Ea+Eb+K)t)((φa(r1)φb(r2)+φa(r2)φb(r1))exp(iJt)+(φa(r1)φb(r2)φa(r2)φb(r1))exp(iJt))(26)=exp(i(Ea+Eb+K)t)(cosJtφa(r1)φb(r2)isinJtφb(r1)φa(r2))

this is reversed when t=π2J.

Author: Christian Cunningham

Created: 2024-05-30 Thu 21:18

Validate